NZ earthquake: How bad?

This week’s earthquake in Christchurch could be the worst insurance catastrophe since Hurricane Ike hit Texas in 2008, according to early reports.

AIR estimates insured losses between US$3.5B and US$8B. JP Morgan estimates $12B. (Ike came in at $12.6B in the U.S. alone, $20B including all Caribbean basin countries, with all numbers updated for inflation).

I don’t have access to the letter to clients that contains Morgan’s estimate, but it sounds a bit like the analyst doubled the loss estimates from September’s New Zealand earthquake, which looks like a $5B to $6B event.

AIR’s original estimate for the September earthquake was $2B to $4.5B, and reinsurers spent much of the fourth quarter raising their estimates on that loss. Bumping AIR’s $4.5B up a third gives you $6B. Doing the same to the $8B estimate gets you around $10.5B.

Before being too harsh on the cat modelers, I should note Scientific American reports the fault whose shifting caused both earthquakes was unknown before it, well, started shifting last year. (h/t Risk Market News via twitter)

I should also point out that AIR’s estimates exclude demand surge – when construction costs soar because raw materials and contractors increase prices because labor and material are in short supply. And I can’t think where demand surge would be greater than an antipodean city of 400,000 struck by two major earthquakes in six months.

So there’s a case to be made that the $12B estimate is low. I think it’s fair to say the city would take decades to rebuild without the reinsurance industry.

For some perspective, $12B is equal to around 10% of New Zealand’s GDP. That would be equivalent to a $1.4 trillion insured loss in the United States.

How bad is that? An asteroid striking Manhattan could create $1.2 trillion in property losses, RMS has estimated (pdf), though that number appears to be total property losses. Insured losses would be somewhat less.

Advertisements
Tagged ,

One thought on “NZ earthquake: How bad?

  1. You say that “An asteroid striking Manhattan could create $1.2 trillion in property losses.” Is that estimate based upon the Yankees being at home or away at the time of the event?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: