Suck it up, pols; everyone deserves fire protection

You’ve heard about this already, the home that burned in Tennessee while the firefighters watched. (My tweet yesterday linked to the insurance angle here.)

I’m sympathetic to the FD and the town of South Fulton on this one, and I think the Cranick family is the victim of incompetent government in their own community.

Fire services are like insurance and if you only charge for them after the fact, you have the classic adverse selection problem. Few will buy the service until they desperately need it. Then, the FD isn’t selling protection, it’s selling loss control. The prices are a lot different, and running an FD on a pay-as-you-go basis is far, far different from running one along the lines we are used to, and really not practical.

Anyone whose house is burning down will tell the fire department he will pay anything to save the property. Is the battalion chief supposed to provide an estimate? Run a credit check? Produce a contract? This is all uber-libertarian silliness.

And I feel sad for the family, but the need to buy fire protection didn’t arise yesterday. Watch the entire four-minute clip. The $75 fee has been public policy for 20 years. A house burned down two years ago in exactly the same circumstances, so there wasn’t a history of forgiving nonpayment. The Cranick family couldn’t have been too surprised, or shouldn’t have been. They made a tragic, tragic mistake.

The ultimate blame here lies with the township the house resides in. Its politicians should suck it up and pay for fire protection, then assess a tax. That tax would come to $1.50 a week – probably quite a bit less – and if the politicians that vote for that tax get voted out of office, well, buddy, you’re getting the government you deserve.

It can be hard to convince some people that public services serve all of the public. For example, would you like to live next to a burned-out house? Would you want to locate a high-tech sophisticated business amid an uneducated populace? (Bermuda is grappling with that issue right now.) The lack of these services hurts everyone in your community, whether everyone uses the service or not.

Tagged ,

3 thoughts on “Suck it up, pols; everyone deserves fire protection

  1. Lyle says:

    I just checked Tennessee does not have townships, there are counties and municipalities only. It turns out only about 1/2 the states have townships that have any function at all. Texas for example has none. The state would need to empower voters to establish an emergency services district with a tax to pay for the service. For the county to put it on its tax roles would double tax the folks in the cities who pay in their city taxes for the service and also would pay in the county tax. Texas has such districts set up to solve just this problem. Taxes range from 30-40 per year on a 100k house.

  2. jimlynch9999 says:

    Sorry, no townships in TN, and a good point about double-taxing town residents.
    Ironically the county has established a 911 district:

  3. I am totally unsympathetic towards the FD. Any good person would lend a hand to someone who’s home and all belongings were being disintegrated.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: